Table of Contents
ToggleIntroduction: Botulinum Toxinās Split PersonalityāPoison and Cureā
You might have heard or read “Botox” being talked about in ads for wrinkle-free skin or listened to the news describe it as “the deadliest substance on Earth.” And the wild part is: āit’s bothā.
Let’s get it straight. Botulinum toxināthe stuff that makes Botox possibleāis produced by a bacterium called Clostridium botulinum. Purified, a single āā1 gram would be enough to kill over 1 million peopleāā. But since 1989, doctors have legally injected diluted versions of this toxin into humans. Why? Because in small, controlled doses, it’s a miracle drug.
Here’s how the shift happened:
ā1989āā: It was initially approved by the FDA to align crossed eyes (strabismus). Ah, paralyzing tiny eye muscles made patients look straight.
āā2002āā: A beauty trend swept the country. The FDA approved Botox for frown lines, and everyone wanted “the toxin” on their face.
āāTodayāā: Over āā7.4 million Americans get Botox every yearāā, and it’s used for migraines to sweaty armpits.
But the lesser-known fact is: āNot all botulinum toxins are made equalāā. There are 8 types (A-H), but only āāType A and Type Bāā are used in medicine. So why does 99% of clinics use Type A (like Botox)? Why would anyone use Type B? And what if you get it wrong?
Let’s remove the hype. No textbook language, no sales talkāraw and straightforward facts you can utilize to make more informed decisions.
The Basics: What Are Botulinum Toxin Type A and Type B?ā
Don’t be fooled by the sci-fi sounding namesāsimply two brothers of the “botox family” with entirely different personalities.
āāā Where are they from?āā
Both are made by the same bacterium: Clostridium botulinum. The toxin that they make āāstops nerve impulsesāāālike you yank a plug out of a cord. Without the “contract” signal, muscles relax. That’s why it can kill you in high doses but smooth out wrinkles in low doses.
ā” Why Type A vs. Type B?āā
Scientists discovered 8 forms of botulinum toxin (A-H), but only āāType A and Type Bāā are utilized in humans. Here’s the lowdown:
āāType Aāā: The “star” of the group, commanding āā65% of the global marketāā (Botox, Dysport, and Xeomin are all Type A products).
āāType Bāā: The underdog. The only product youāll find is āāMyoblocāā (U.S.) or āāNeuroblocāā (Europe), mostly used for medical issues, not selfies.
āā⢠How different are their “body types”?āā
Hereās a twist: Type A has a molecular weight of āā150 kDaāā, while Type B is actually āā700 kDaāā (kDa = kilodalton, a unit to measure molecule size).
Wait, isn’t 700 more than 150? Yepābut here’s the twist: āāType B’s molecule is smallerāā due to it being a “single-chain” shape, compared to Type A making a bulkier “complex” with other proteins. This makes Type B diffuse faster in your bodyāfor better or worse.
Fun fact: There is only āāā0.0000001 gramsāā of actual toxin in one vial of Botox (Type A). So what’s the rest of it made of? Albumin and saltwater. Myobloc (Type B) is 3x stronger, thoughāit’s why it takes effect faster but doesn’t last as long.
Core Difference #1: Speed vs. Staying Powerā
Get real: You’re putting poison into your face (or neck, or underarms), you’d better know what you’re doing to your body. Here’s the scoop on how quickly these poisons workāand for how long.
āāType A (Botox, Dysport, Xeomin):
āāWhen it kicks ināā: 3-7 days (you’ll notice fine lines vanishing just when you need it for your next Zoom meeting).
āāLastsāā: 3-6 months. For cosmetic uses, most people get āā4 monthsāā of smooth skin before needing a top-up.
āāBest forāā: Anyone who hates scheduling appointments. āSet it and forget itā types.
āāType B (Myobloc/Neurobloc):āā
āāKicks ināā: 24-72 hours (think āovernight reliefā for medical issues).
āāLastsāā: 2-3 months max. Youāll be back in the doctorās office before your next haircut.
āāBest forāā: āFix me NOWā situations.
āāReal-life exampleāā:
Sarah, 45, a teacher, has cervical dystoniaāspasms of pain in her neck. She began on Type A, but waiting a week for relief to kick in was “like torture.” Her doctor changed her to Type B. “The next morning, I could turn my head without crying,” she says. The catch? She must have injections every 10 weeks.
āāYour cheat sheetā
Wedding lines ruining your wedding? āāType Aāā (be patient!).
Need to ease nervous sweats during interviews tomorrow? āāType Bāā (preparing for a few more needles).
Why it matters:
āāBotox isn’t a one-size-fits-allāā. Type A’s slower time to peak actually makes it safer for cosmetic useāless chance for the toxin to travel where it shouldn’t.
Type B speed is two ways about it: Fast action = faster fade. In a 2021 study, published in Neurology, researchers concluded that 68% of patients who were given Myobloc needed to have the injections redone within less than 3 months, whereas 22% of patients who were treated with Botox needed to have the injections redone.
Conclusion: āāPerseverance or speed? You can’t have both.āā Do it by your tolerance level and if you enjoy hearing your doctor’s waiting room music.
Core Difference #2: What Can They Actually Treat? (Spoiler: Type A Does Almost Everything)ā
Think of Type A as the Swiss Army knife of botulinum toxinsāitās FDA-approved for both your wrinklesĀ andĀ your weirdest medical issues. Type B? Itās more like a specialty tool youād grab for one specific job. Letās break down who gets what:
āāType A (Botox) ā The Overachieverāā
- āāCosmetic Usesāā:
- Frown lines (2002 FDA approval)
- Crowās feet (2013)
- Forehead lines (2017)
- Bonus: Many docs use it “off-label” for jaw slimming, bunny lines, even a “lip flip.”
- āāMedical Usesāā:
- Chronic migraines (31% of users get ā„50% fewer headaches)
- Hyperhidrosis (stops sweaty pits for 82% of people for 4-12 months)
- Overactive bladder (reduces bathroom trips by 3x daily)
- Even crossed eyes and eyelid spasms
āāType B (Myobloc) ā The Niche Playerāā
- āāOnly FDA-Approved Forāā:
- Cervical dystonia (neck muscle spasms ā 2000 approval)
- Chronic drooling (2019)
- āāOff-Label Dramaāā: Some rogue clinics inject Type B for forehead wrinkles, but hereās why thatās sketchy:
- It spreads faster (hello, droopy eyelids)
- Lasts half as long as Botox
- Not a single long-term safety study for cosmetic use
āāThe Elephant in the Roomāā: Why isnāt Type B approved for beauty fixes?
- āāFDA Saysāā: āNo sufficient evidence.ā Translation: Drug makers havenāt bothered to spend millions testing it for wrinkles when Type A already dominates.
- āāReal-World Hackāā: A 2022 survey found 14% of medspas secretly mix Type B with Type A for āfaster results,ā but experts call it āplaying Russian roulette with facial muscles.ā
āāPro Tipāā: If a clinic offers āBotox alternativesā that work overnight, askĀ exactlyĀ whatās in the syringe. Type B labels must say āMyoblocā or ārimabotulinumtoxinBā ā no sneaky rebranding allowed.
Core Difference #3: Side Effects & The “Immunity” Trapā
Letās be blunt: Injecting neurotoxins isnāt risk-free. But hereās the kickerāāāType A and Type B bite back in totally different waysāā.
āThe Side Effect Showdownāā
āāType A (Botox)āā:
- āāCommon issuesāā (5% of users):
- Swelling (like a mosquito bite where injected)
- Headaches (usually fades in 48 hours)
- āāRare but scaryāā: Droopy eyelids (1 in 250 cases) if it spreads
āāType B (Myobloc)āā:
- āā”Why is my mouth so dry?”āā: 15% of users report:
- Cottonmouth (like after dental numbing)
- Trouble swallowing (imagine food stuck in your throat)
- āāWhy itās riskierāā: Smaller molecules wander farther from injection sites. A 2020 Johns Hopkins study found Type B spreads āā3x fartherāā than Type A.
The Immunity Time Bombāā
Hereās what nobody tells you: āāYour body can fight backāā.
- āāType Aāā: 1-3% of frequent users develop antibodies within āā2 yearsāā, making Botox useless.
- Real math: If you get injections every 3 months, your risk jumps to āā10% after 5 yearsāā.
- Source: 2006 Neurology study tracking 631 patients
- āāType Bāā: Less than 0.5% develop resistance. Why? Your immune system struggles to recognize its structure.
Doctorsā Dirty Little Secretāā
Plastic surgeons have a hack for Botox veterans: āāSwitch to Type B every third injectionāā.
āāCase in pointāā: Jane, 38, got Botox every 2 months for migraines. After 3 years, it stopped working. Her neurologist switched her to Myobloc for one cycle. Result: Botox worked again for another 18 months.
āāBut warningāā: This isnāt a free pass. Type Bās harsh side effects mean most people only tolerate 1-2 rounds of this “detox.”
āYour Survival Guideāā
- If youāre getting injected āāmore than 4x a yearāā, ask your doctor about antibody testing (yes, it exists).
- Type B isnāt a “safer” alternativeāitās just playing different Russian roulette.
- Stopping suddenly? Bad idea. One study found āā62% of chronic usersāā had worse symptoms than pre-treatment if they quit cold turkey.
āāPro tipāā: āIf your Botox stops lasting 3 months, donāt just up the doseāyou might be breeding immunity,ā says Dr. Emily Kirby (Fort Worth dermatologist). āSwitch areas or take a 6-month break.ā
Bottom line: Your bodyās not stupid. Treat botulinum toxins like a strong whiskeyāoccasional shots work, but daily chugging will burn you.
The Hidden Difference: Why Molecule Size Is a Big Freaking Dealā
You know how a precision scalpel works better for eye surgery than a butter knife? Botulinum toxins follow the same rule. The size of their molecules decidesĀ exactlyĀ where they go in your bodyāand that changes everything.
Type A: The Sniper Rifleāā
- āāMolecular weightāā: 150 kDa (but forms a heavy “complex” with proteins, acting like a 900 kDa bullet).
- āāSpread radiusāā: Stays within āā1-2 cmāā of the injection site.
- āāWhy itās perfect forāā:
- āāGlabellar linesāā (the ā11ā between eyebrows) ā You donāt want toxin creeping into eyelids.
- āāLip flipāā ā Precise upper lip muscle targeting.
- āāReal-world proofāā: A 2018Ā Plastic Surgery JournalĀ study mapped toxin spread using dye. Type A stayed put; Type B wandered āā30% fartherāā.
Type B: The Shotgunāā
- āāMolecular weightāā: 700 kDa technically, but itās a lightweight single-chain molecule that zips through tissue.
- āāSpread radiusāā: Up to āā3 cmāā ā enough to hit multiple neck muscles in one jab.
- āāWhy clinics love/hate itāā:
- āāProāā: Great for cervical dystonia (neck spasms need broad coverage).
- āāConāā: A 2021 report found Type B accidentally paralyzed throat muscles in 1/200 patients vs. 1/10,000 for Type A.
āāThe Doctorās Playbookāā
Dr. Raj Kanodia (Beverly Hills plastic surgeon) explains:
- āāType Aāā for āmicrozonesā like crowās feet: āI use 1/100th of a milliliter per injection point. Type B would be overkill.ā
- āāType Bāā for medical bulk jobs: āFor severe underarm sweating, I might pick Type B to blanket the area faster.ā
āāBut hereās the catchāā: Once injected, you canāt control where the molecules wander. Type Bās sneaky spread is why the FDA freaks about using it for beauty.
Your Takeawayāā
- āāFace/Precision work?āā Type A only.
- āāLarge muscles/medical?āā Type B could workāif youāre okay with side effect roulette.
- āāNever let a clinicāā use Type B around your eyes, lips, or forehead unless you want the āJoker smileā effect.
Molecule size isnāt just science jargonāitās the invisible hand deciding whether you leave the clinic glowing⦠or go viral on TikTok for all the wrong reasons.
How to Choose: A No-BS Decision Guide (Table + 3 Questions)ā
Cut through the noise with this cheat sheet. No medical degree required.
The Comparison Table Youāll Actually Useāā
Factor | Type A (Botox) | Type B (Myobloc) |
---|---|---|
āāDurationāā | 3-6 months (avg. 4 for wrinkles) | 2-3 months |
āāFDA Approved Forāā | 10+ uses (cosmetic + 8 medical) | 2 medical conditions only |
āāBest Forāā | Long-term results, precision targeting | Fast relief for neck/spasm emergencies |
āāSide Effectsāā | Mild (5% get headaches) | Dry mouth (15%), swallowing issues |
āāCostāā | 300ā600 per area | 20% cheaper, but needs 2x more shots |
Data sources: FDA.gov, 2023 American Society of Plastic Surgeons report
3 Questions to Ask Yourselfāā
āā1. āWhatās my goal?āāā
- āāChoose A ifāā: Youāre fixing wrinkles, preventing migraines, or hate needles.
- āāConsider B ifāā: You have cervical dystonia or drooling so severe youād try anything.
āā2. āHow often do I want injections?āāā
- āāA usersāā: Happy with 3x yearly? Stick to Botox.
- āāB usersāā: Willing to visit every 8-10 weeks? Myobloc might work.
āā3. āCan I handle side effects?āāā
- āāRisk-averse?āā Type Aās 5% headache rate beats Type Bās 15% dry mouth hell.
- āāPro tipāā: If youāve failed Botox (1-3% immunity risk), Type B becomes plan Bāliterally.
Botulinum Toxin Myths Busted: Stop Believing These Liesā
Letās torch the BS floating around TikTok and shady medspa brochures.
Myth 1: āType B is Safer Than Type Aāāā
āāTruthāā:Ā Hell no.Ā Type Bās smaller molecules spread like gossip in a small town.
- āāDanger zoneāā: A 2021 study found Type B reaches āā3x more muscle fibersāā than Type A. Great for neck spasms, terrible for your face.
- āāReal riskāā: 15% of Myobloc users get dry mouth vs. 5% with Botox. One womanās ānatural lip flipā with Type B left her unable to sip soup for 3 weeks.
Myth 2: āYou Can DIY Botox at Homeāāā
āāTruthāā: The FDA has āāneverāā approved self-injection kits. Not once. Not ever.
- āāHorror storyāā: In 2022, a Florida influencer paralyzed her eyebrow muscle using black-market Type A. Repair cost: $8,200.
- āāWhy itās illegalāā: Botulinum toxin is a āāSchedule II controlled substanceāāāsame category as cocaine. You need a license just to transport it.
Myth 3: āThe Toxin Stays in Your Body Foreverāāā
āāTruthāā: Your liver breaks it down like last nightās tequila.
- āāMetabolism factsāā:
- Type A fully clears in āā4-6 monthsāā (traces undetectable after 180 days).
- Type B vanishes fasterāgone by āā90 daysāā.
- āāScience smackdownāā: A 2019 UCLA study tracked radioactive-tagged Botox. Result: 0% remained after 6 months.
āThe Golden Ruleāā
If a medspa saysĀ anyĀ of these myths, run. Fast. Your face isnāt their guinea pig.